Reason why redundant

How can't be used at all as a relative pronoun; one may use that , or nothing at all, but how which refers to way is ungrammatical as a relative marker.

Why and the reason are redundant. From Merriam-Webster Online :. Sign up to join this community. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top. Stack Overflow for Teams — Collaborate and share knowledge with a private group. Create a free Team What is Teams? Learn more. Asked 8 years, 3 months ago. Active 2 months ago.

Viewed k times. Improve this question. Add a comment. Open slather, perhaps? November 21, at am. Am I right? There are some million native speakers, and it is the medium of communication for many millions more : it is the most widely used second language in the world. It belongs to the West Germanic group of Indo-European languages, though its vocabulary has been much influenced by Norman French and Latin. I can provide answers, but what is the purpose? In Mexico, there are many languages used, but the de facto standard is Spanish.

However, as we all know, that is a variety of that used in Spain. They would never accept a description of it being Spanish Spanish.

The same attitude would apply in France and other countries. Tell me, what was the name for the English spoken in Britain before Standard English came along?

November 24, at pm. So Standard English is only spoken in the UK, right, 11goalposts? We cannot say that the Americans speak Standard English, right?

November 25, at pm. Standard English is a construct that applies appropriately in particular contexts of use, for example, publishing, academics, and broadcasting. The whole point of standardization is to enhance communication in wider contexts. Even though there are trivial differences between standard American and standard British English, those differences are not an impediment to mutual understanding.

There are, of course, contexts where it is appropriate to refer to British English or American English, particularly in second language teaching and in the marketing of ESL materials. The results ultimately depend upon whose media you watch and read. By the way, there are probably more distinct dialects in Great Britain than in the rest of the English speaking world.

And, as some commenters have pointed out, the language spoken in England has changed just as much in the past years as has the language spoken in North America. My dear chap,, that is exactly what they do do.

I repeat that these terms are common in education, linguistics, and grammar. There are many varieties of English and there are standard abbreviations for them. I speak NZE, for example. It is the language academics who taught me the argument. There is simply no argument about it. Even the most rigid prescriptivists accept that usages that were once considered incorrect become standard if used frequently enough.

If a significant majority of literate speakers from all walks life use a particular form and it is used over a long period of time then it will become standard, just as the meanings of words alter through usage. November 28, at am. A lot of this has become quibbling over what I see as a very very minor point — what label to assign to a set of dialects — so let me offer my brief thought in an attempt to smooth this over and return to more interesting debates.

I say that I speak English, as I say about a variety of friends whose various accents and grammars render their form of English at times unintelligible to me.

November 28, at pm. GABE Thanks for the response. I was drawn to this site because it specifically distanced itself from prescriptivism and related websites, where it was claimed that there were adherents to punctuation and grammar — in the main — which were overly fussy and allowed no flexibility with the language. I applaud the intention of Motivated Grammar.

On the other hand, I have expressed views which have clearly been disagreed with strongly, but perhaps mainly on the differences in language uses between the USA and the UK. It has always been very interesting to read about the development of expression and spelling from historical times from the OED, in particular.

Further, was no formality on expression, and even punctuation was only being developed. There were, of course, enormous benefits to that. Unfortunately, in recent times, some people have been taking some very minor and, perhaps, subjective points and insisting there was no room for flexibility — I disagree with that stance.

I seem to be in a minority of one , so my views on Standard English will only inflame readers, it appears. Regards, elevengoalposts. November 29, at pm. Stan: I forgot to mention that you raised a great point. Sometimes you need a place to vent, or at least I do. December 5, at pm. Elevengoalposts has presented the same argument and reacted in the same way on many other forums. December 17, at am. February 26, at pm. Wrong, wrong , wrong. Just Speak correctly!

June 1, at am. July 3, at pm. Whys, Becauses, e um pouco mais! July 6, at pm. August 26, at am. Elevengoalpoast I enjoyrd ur discussion. U made de best points. I dont like to use dat expression :. September 24, at am. Is it acceptable. November 2, at pm. Redundancy is bad in a newspaper because space is valuable. Why would you have ever thought that in the first place?! April 11, at pm. It is unnecessary. May 8, at pm. July 31, at pm. I should have read all of the responses to the original post before responding.

A swimsuit can be dry. As far as redundancy goes, a dry swimsuit is possible. I actually have one in my dresser right now. I have not come across that yet. October 6, at pm. November 20, at am. Kw Jung. This is probably more something you hear in informal everyday conversation rather than see in print, but I like to think very basic rules should be observed even in informal settings.

Actively condemning its usage would deprive us of this tool. So, I say, reason why ahead.. Compare sentence a with sentence b a the reason why this is yellow is that it is… alternatively: the reason that this is yellow is that it is. The reason being that there should be a moderator to give a conclusive opinion. Reason is a noun, so a clause or phrase modifying a noun must be adjectival.

Learn some grammar. Isaac Murphy, that is very convincing. But I would like to have a really solid understanding of why it is incorrect, or correct, as the case may be. Periodically I ask Google and see what the latest bloggers have to say. Bob They do seem parallel. Parallel and wrong. I agree with Bob Hearn. Again, language is arbitrary. Subscribe to my monthly e-newsletter to receive writing and grammar tips.

Business writing , Choose the right word , Online writing blog , Resources , Words resources , Writing resources. Online writing blog , Resources , Writing resources.